When the Deck Seems Stacked, Helping Kids Beat the Odds
By Jonathan F. Zaff, Founding Director of the CERES Institute for Children & Youth
This blog post was originally posted on America’s Promise Alliance’s website.
Where you live can determine where you’ll go. That’s the big takeaway from a recent study conducted by economist and McArthur “genius” award winner Raj Chetty and his team at Harvard.
Overall, growing up in a high-poverty neighborhood substantially hurts your chances of moving up the economic ladder. Born into poverty in L.A., Chicago, or the Bronx? Your economic and educational opportunities are constrained. Your chances of becoming a teen parent rise.
You could move to Providence (Rhode Island), San Francisco, or Salt Lake City, where your economic, educational, and social chances would improve, but that’s hardly practical or even possible for most. The answer has to lie in community-wide efforts to improve opportunities for all, wherever they live.
In our work at the Center for Promise, we continue to identify high-poverty communities that have transformed the opportunities for children, youth and families and improved academic and economic outcomes. Three such communities – East Lake in Atlanta (Georgia), Parramore in Orlando (Florida), and East Durham (North Carolina) – offer hope to other communities. They’ve reduced violence, increased early childhood readiness, and boosted elementary and secondary school academic outcomes.
Another important finding from Chetty and his colleagues: Improving a community helps young people, whether they are infants or adolescents. The effects add up over young lifetimes, adding to a mountain of data showing the benefits of investing in early childhood.
Investing in adolescents is hardly a lost cause, whether early or late. Research shows that young people continue to develop cognitively and emotionally, leaving room for interventions that can change lives.
We heard that loud and clear from the young people who participated in our study, Don’t Call Them Dropouts. These young adults too often faced life obstacles that far outweighed their capacity to overcome them – and yet, they sometimes found a way to succeed.
Some young people re-engaged with inspiring programs – like YouthBuild, Learning Works at Homeboy Industries, and the United Teen Equality Center – which built on their strengths and offered a constellation of relationships that provided the emotional support and life guidance they were missing.
For young adults whose first homes created obstacles instead of reducing them, these centers became second homes that opened doors. Where they live now will determine where they can go.
And that’s what we want for all our kids.
Jonathan F. Zaff is Research Professor, Applied Human Development and the Founding Director of the CERES Institute for Children & Youth at the Boston University Wheelock College of Education & Human Development.
The latest research from CERES Institute, released in February 2022, shares the lived experiences of high school students as they navigated a drastically altered world during the 2020–2021 school year.
In partnership with MENTOR (the National Mentoring Partnership), CERES Institute is working with a set of school districts on how they can develop a “relationships strategy” for their schools. CERES Institute will serve as a research and evaluation partner for MENTOR during this three-year initiative.
In Florida, thanks to a robust school choice environment, parents of students with disabilities have access to several educational options through two specific statewide scholarship programs. To shed light on how parents utilize these scholarships, a team of researchers from CERES Institute for Children and Youth, in partnership with the Department of Education Reform at the University of Arkansas, share findings from a mixed-methods study, conducted between fall 2020 to spring 2021, as well as implications for policy and practice.
CERES Institute and the National Center for Learning Disabilities (NCLD) are partnering on a mixed methods research study to develop a deeper understanding of general educators’ experiences teaching students with learning and attention issues during the COVID-19 pandemic.
How can Debate-Inspired Classrooms better engage students as leaders in their own learning? The CERES Institute for Children & Youth is partnering with the Boston Debate League and Boston Public Schools’ Dr. William W. Henderson Inclusion School to answer this question and more.
The CERES Institute for Children & Youth is examining how the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Department of Youth Services’ Youth Engaged in Services Initiative – the YES Initiative – provides voluntary individualized supports to youth involved with the juvenile justice system and the impact of the YES Initiative on youth recidivism rates.
The Center for Promise is the applied research institute of America’s Promise Alliance, housed at Boston University Wheelock College of Education & Human Development. Its mission is to develop a deep understanding of the conditions necessary for young people in the United States to succeed in school and life.